I've been meaning to write this for some time. Here goes.

As a resident of the American Pacific Northwest (Oregon, Washington, Idaho and British Columbia) it has long been evident to me that archaeology suffers from being too Euro-centric. It's developed a distinct bias toward mankind developing in a certain way, as in Europe. Gobekli Tepe may be demonstrating that that wasn't always so.

Certainly here in the Northwest it hasn't exactly followed the script. There had been substantial Native villages persisting for centuries despite local civilization never moving past the hunter-gatherer stage. As Michael has surmised, why would one, if all needs were met? Well, this area is very rich in resources, so it didn't! As one Native woman once said on public television "We didn't have agriculture, but we sure had horticulture." 

I remember reading an historical account of a correspondence between local settler women complaining of Native women coming by their garden patches and wailing and weeping, which the white ladies could not understand. Of course their gardens had been planted in the best places for growing, hence no doubt replacing native plants that didn't look like "food" to white eyes, but "just" blue lilies. (The native crop of camas plants, which the "Indians" had fostered in place for centuries, the bulbs of which were a staple that, among other things, could be stored in pits for ages after being blanched to stop sprouting, and which are rich in vitamin C.) The local tribes did not resist the incomers very much, but we must have seemed very destructive to them, especially the gatherer population!

This lead me to think about how agriculture would come about and I thought of all the herding cultures, most of which moved their herds in season to new pastures. Well, they must have then, as now, brought along hay and grain to help the livestock through sparse areas. And eventually this spillage of grain would result in an evident change as patches of "new" plants would appear along their customary paths. Eventually some bright soul would make the connection that certain plants could be made to grow in new places by virtue of seeds! "Aha! I think if we put these grains in the ground, we could move our favorite plants to places that served us better!" He or she was probably ridiculed at first until their experiment proved itself.This would have taken an entire season to prove itself valid. "See! I planted some grain there last year! Have oats ever grown there before?" Hence the discovery of planting, hence agriculture.

Viola!

I believe Gobekli Tepe is more a celebration of the discovery that pregnancy was not magic, and that males did have a function vis-a-vis procreation after all. I'd think male animals in the herd would seem to be a waste of resources until one realised the herd could not produce new animals without them. After all, the notion that procreation was magic persisted into historic times despite evidence to the contrary. This explains all the phallic symbology and the work that went into the buildings. "Let us celebrate this new discovery that liberates men from 'merely' being the protectors." Whoopee!

Hoping you find my musings interesting,

Suzanne Hammond

moreachrammstein@gmail.com 

Comments

Popular Posts