Aha! Now I know why the classic hunter-gatherer and then agriculturalist progression archaeologists use, always seemed wrong, too simplistic, to me.

I was just watching a locally-produced video on the history of how badly we treated Native Americans during the “pioneer” era and a Native lady said “they said we were ‘wasting’ the land because we didn’t use it for agriculture, but we were doing horticulture”. And that’s the missing part! Before there was recognizable “agriculture” there was a long tradition of horticulture. There must have been. Maize didn’t domesticate itself! While mankind was still practicing hunting and gathering and being mostly nomadic, they were also familiarizing themselves with the plants humans could eat, and I suspect in many cases they were tending to the welfare of such plants in situ, without moving them into domestic fields. I recall that local pioneers were baffled when “Indian” women showed up when they were plowing and moaned and cried. Well unbeknownst to them, their plowing was destroying long-beloved and lovingly tended “crops” that already grew there “naturally” such as the Camas, a beautiful blue lily whose bulbs were a staple of native diets, easy to preserve and high in vitamin C.

The reason the “pioneering of the West” was so wrong was because a successful hunter-gatherer lifestyle requires a much larger territory. The vast, seemingly “open” spaces included the many scattered places where the things to gather lived. Berry bushes over here, bulbs there, and roots over there, grains elsewhere, plus clams and muscles and other such treasures best left to the gatherers. Some were miles apart. Before mankind learned how to adapt ground into fields where such plants easily grew, they grew where their natures were best adapted. We spent tens of thousands of years identifying them before we ever realized we could domesticate them completely and add to local soil to make them “happy” there. Wine grapes still grow better on hillsides, and grains on the flats, but at least we can move them a bit closer to where we like to live. And we’ve developed transplanting.

Comments

Popular Posts