Why does Russia believe it should own Ukraine?
Not much Eastern European history is taught in American schools. This may be a mistake. Ever since the Russian Revolution it's been useful for us to know this type of history.
First of all, the history of Russia started in Kyiv! What? Yes, because Kyiv is located on one of the great rivers, the Dneiper. You see Russia was founded by the Russ, a squad or clan of Vikings, not Slavs. As was Viking custom, Norsemen often dragged their dragon ships across lowlands and swamps into nearby rivers to explore, and possibly make claims. The Norse Lords of the Isles did this all over western Scotland in order to claim a larger area than just the actual islands. So with the Russ in the Dneiper. Hence Kyiv, and eventually Russia. In a sense Kyiv was once the capital of Russia. But Russia and the Ukraine were not really one entity. Ukraine the someday country was largely populated by peoples like the Crimean Tartars and the Cossacks, whereas what became modern Russia was more fully Slavic. In any case, this gives the Russians a huge piece of shared history with Ukraine.
Furthermore, since the Russian Revolution created Soviet Russia, and sovietism in general, it also eventually brought to power Stalin. (Oddly enough not a Russian but a Georgian. Georgia is also a country east of Russia.) Stalin was a ruthless ruler and often mistreated those groups under the Soviet system of uniting large parts of Eastern Europe and northern Asia. Ukraine was badly mistreated as the "breadbasket" agricultural area that fed much of the Soviet Union. Starvation and punishment were the order of the day during the worldwide Great Depression. In Ukraine, this predictably lead to deaths, resentment and hatred and a longing for independence.
When Gorbachev dissolved the Soviet Union, he set Ukraine free. But before then some Ukrainians were willing to do just about anything to get away from Russia, including fighting for the German side during WWII! I doubt they were true Nazis. No one really knew all the terrors the Nazis were up to before their defeat. I'm sure, since Nazi doctrine insisted all Slavs were among the lower orders and I'm pretty sure the German High Command didn't recognize that Tartars were not Slavs, that after they'd won, the Ukrainians would have been bundled off to the death camps along with Jews, Gypsies and other "lower" peoples. The enemy of your enemy is not always your friend!
So Putin has grasped onto this small bit of history to claim that Ukraine is not really a country at all, belongs in Russia, and that all Ukrainians who want a free Ukraine are "Nazis", even if Jewish! Furthermore his spies in Ukraine, in order not to offend the boss, seem to have reported that most Ukrainians agreed and that taking Ukraine back would be a snap! Russian troops weren't even told where they were going or expected to do! Sadly for the troops, the Ukrainians did not agree. In fact they disagreed very vigorously! So now we have memes of Snake Island guards flipping off the Russian Navy and Ukrainian farm tractors pulling Russian tanks off the battlefield. We have learned enough Ukrainian to recognize "Slava Ukraine" means Glory to Ukraine. This fight has indeed been glorious with enough sacrifice and heroism to fill books and plays. My greatest hope is that they win, but even if they don't, this will go down as one of the great struggles of history. Слава Україні!
Comments
Post a Comment